Appley Ever After

Appley Ever After

$25
Earn 25 Reward Points on your order.

Appley Ever After is a rich and sophisticated brick red gluten free lipstick. It’s not bright and it’s not dark – it strikes a perfect middle and is super wearable. If you’ve been looking for the “best red lipstick that won’t turn pink” and you have cool or neutral skin – Appley Ever After is the shade you’ve been searching for.

It leans darker on medium to dark skin and will be more classic red on light to fair skin. This shade is best for cool and neutral skin and it will not turn pink. Warm skin will do better with Barcelona, Strawberry Lips or Risque. Shimmer, nut and fragrance free.

Quantity
Earn up to 25 Points on this purchase.

Formula: Instant Color

Ingredients: Helianthus Annus (Sunflower) Seed Oil, Euphorbia Cerifera (Candelilla) Wax, Butyrospermum Parkii, Synthetic Beeswax, Copernicia Cerifera (Carnauba) Wax, Tocopheryl Acetate, May Contain: Titanium Dioxide, Manganese Violet, Mica, Iron Oxide 

Key Ingredients: Sunflower Oil gives this lipstick its soft and creamy texture. Vitamin E provides a moisturizing feel, helping lips feel smooth and comfortable. Red Apple Lipstick was one of the first to use Sunflower Oil in lipstick in 2012, setting a high standard for creamy, colorful lipsticks.


  • Gluten Free Lipstick
  • Moisturizing and Hydrating
  • Antioxidant Protection
  • Smooth Application
  • Formulated To Support Clean Beauty Lovers
  • Vegan
  • Cruelty Free – Leaping Bunny Certified
  • Synthetic Fragrance Free
  • Phthalate Free
  • Soy Free
  • Petroleum Free
  • Sustainably Sourced Ingredients
  • Palm Oil Free
  • PCR Plastic Tube
  • Highest Quality Ingredients
  • Organic Plant Based Ingredients, Minimally Processed
  • Safe Synthetics

new-lip-brush-psd

Pairs Well With

Out of stock

Vegan + Cruelty Free

Gluten-Free & Non-Toxic

Hydrating & Non-Drying

Lasting, Beautiful Color

Deeply Moisturizing – No More Dry Lips

Our ultra-nourishing formula is packed with soothing, hydrating ingredients like Vitamin E and rich botanical oils, making it the best lipstick for dry lips. Say goodbye to chapped lips and hello to lasting comfort.

Gluten-Free & Safe for Sensitive Skin

Meticulously crafted to be the best gluten-free, vegan, and non-toxic lipsticks you've ever worn, making it perfect for your sensitivities or auto-immune concerns. Enjoy high-performance color without irritation.

Smooth, Creamy & Lightweight

Unlike waxy, drying formulas, our lipstick glides on effortlessly with a buttery-soft, creamy texture. It feels weightless, never sticky or heavy, for a truly comfortable wear.

"I love this lipstick. It's finally the perfect red for me as it's not too bright, not to dark, and long lasting."

Frequenty Asked Questions

Customer Reviews
4.8 Based on 51 Reviews
5 ★
88% 
45
4 ★
4% 
2
3 ★
4% 
2
2 ★
4% 
2
1 ★
0% 
0
Customer Photos
Write a Review Ask a Question

Thank you for submitting a review!

Your input is very much appreciated. Share it with your friends so they can enjoy it too!

Filter Reviews:
  • 1940
  • fullsize
  • reds
  • undertone
  • stain
  • deal
  • samples
  • Rebel
  • customer service
  • order
GH
02/07/2025
GinaLoretta H.
United States
  • What's your beauty style? Classic
  • What's your age range? 60-69

Actually Rebel

I had to change my order and the customer service was so helpful in changing my order to Rebel. I'm so glad they were able to change it to Rebel, this red is the true dark red with a deep blue undertone! I have tried 9 reds before this, some fullsize, some were samples. They all looked good at first, then they turned orangey. This one is the real deal! It feels good on and when it wears off, it leaves a nice stain. Finally, I have a beautiful dark red lipstick just like my mom wore from the 1940s.

Red Apple Lipstick Appley Ever After Review
DZ
01/01/2025
Diane Z.
United States

Perfect Red

This lipstick is creamy and soothing. I apply after the Rallye Balm. The color can look like a blush of color or be built up and lined to look bold. I have very light hair and pale skin. The beauty of this shade is that it wakes up the face without shouting. BUT! It can shout if you apply it differently. I teach hot yoga and a little pop is great, especially for those 6:00 am classes.

BW
11/14/2024
Brittani W.
United States

Yes, Ma’am!

Consider this lipstick your own personal hype-woman in a tube! Wear it on date night or even to dress up your usual T-shirt-and-jeans outfit. Mwah! 💋

MB
09/10/2024
Melinda B.
US

Good product but color is not true

The lipstick and rich and creamy and thick, stays on well, but colors are not true when applied.

KR
07/31/2024
kathleen r.
US

Great red!

Beautiful red color that’s long lasting too. Love it!